Blog

Local vs overseas clothing manufacturing: an honest comparison

A globe with a world map

This argument gets ugly fast, usually because the two sides are comparing different things. Local production is expensive per unit and cheap per mistake. Overseas is the reverse. Which one is right depends on how many mistakes you can afford to make, and how much cash you can tie up while you find out.

What local actually costs

In the US or UK, cut and sew for a basic tee runs 12 to 25 dollars per unit at 200 to 500 units. In China it is 3 to 5 dollars. In Vietnam, 2.80 to 4.50. Those numbers are real and they are not going to converge.

But the local number includes things the overseas number does not. No duty. No ocean freight. No 30 day transit. No 12 hour time difference when something goes wrong. You can drive to the factory, and on a bad day that is worth more than the per unit saving.

Local also means lower minimums. A small US shop might take 50 units. Almost no overseas factory will touch that, and the ones that will are not the ones you want.

What overseas actually costs

The 3 dollar tee is not 3 dollars landed. Add freight, which for a 500 unit order of tees is roughly 800 to 1,500 dollars depending on the route. Add duty, 12 to 32 percent depending on the country and the fiber. Add the agent fee if you use one, 3 to 5 percent.

On 3,000 dollars of goods, that is often 1,500 to 2,000 dollars of extra cost. Landed cost per unit goes from 3 to 4.20. Still a fraction of local. But the gap is smaller than the FOB price suggests, and it narrows further if you air freight.

  • Ocean freight. 25 to 40 days door to door, plus 5 to 10 days for customs.
  • Air freight. 5 to 8 days, at 4 to 6 times the cost. Only worth it for samples or a hot restock.
  • Duty. Rates vary by HS code and origin. A cotton knit tee from China into the US is 16.5 percent. From Vietnam it can be lower depending on which trade agreement is in force that year.
  • Payment. Most factories want 30 percent deposit before they buy fabric, and you are wiring money to a company you may never visit.

The mistakes that only happen far away

The cost nobody puts in a spreadsheet is the cost of a mistake you find out about three weeks late. A wrong label, a shade that does not match, a fit that is 2cm off. Locally you catch it in a day and fix it. Overseas you catch it when the container arrives, and the fix is a new order and another six weeks.

That is a real cost. It is just not a line item, so it never appears in the comparison charts. Brands that go overseas too early, before their specs are stable, tend to pay it once and then either fix their process or come home.

When local wins

Local wins when you are still figuring out the product. Small runs, frequent changes, tight deadlines, or a market that pays 90 dollars for a sweatshirt and expects it in two weeks. It also wins when your size range includes hard-to-grade bodies and you need to fit on real people quickly, and for made-to-order models where the whole appeal is a 10 day restock.

When overseas wins

Overseas wins when the product is stable. You have made it three times, the pattern is locked, and the only variable is quantity. Then the 70 percent cost gap is free money, and the lead time is a planning problem rather than a risk.

Plenty of brands end up hybrid. Overseas for the core line, local for samples, small runs, and late add-ons. It is more admin work and it usually makes sense once you are past a certain size.

The honest version is that overseas saves money on volume and costs money on uncertainty. If your uncertainty is high, pay for local until it is not. Once it is low, geography stops mattering and you should go where the unit cost is.

Ready to start your brand?

Tell us what you want to make and we'll tell you honestly whether it's worth it.

Contact Us